Soprano’s Market

Nestled in the heart of Waverly, NY, Soprano’s Market is a delightful fusion of breakfast restaurant, deli, and casual Italian eatery that charms both locals and visitors alike. This inviting spot serves up a rich variety of Italian-American comfort foods with an unmistakable warmth and authenticity that is reflected not only in their cuisine but also in the welcoming atmosphere.

The real star of Soprano’s is its diverse menu that beautifully balances hearty breakfast options, classic deli offerings, and indulgent baked goods. Imagine waking up to a Bacon Ham Sausage and Egg Breakfast Pizza—a savory, cheesy, and protein-packed dish that hits all the right notes for a fulfilling start to your day. Or savor one of their expertly crafted omelets such as The Italiano, brimming with spicy ham, sausage, provolone, roasted peppers, and mushrooms, each bite bursting with layered flavors that only a kitchen passionate about tradition can deliver.

Lunchtime at Soprano’s Market is equally impressive. Their homemade tuna, egg, chicken, and seafood salads—served as subs or wraps—showcase freshness and care in every ingredient, from crisp celery to perfectly balanced seasonings. For salad lovers, the Antipasto Salad, loaded with cappocola ham, Genoa salami, provolone cheese, black olives, and pepperoncini, offers a vibrant, savory crunch that feels both satisfying and wholesome. The Chef Salad and Caesar options present a deliciously elevated take on familiar classics, making every lunch visit a culinary delight.

Beyond the savory, Soprano’s Market shines with an irresistible selection of baked goods and desserts that have become local legends. From the gooey, caramel apple filled cupcakes to the tantalizing chocolate-dipped cannoli eclairs, every sweet treat feels handcrafted with love. The deep dish pizza slices, especially the garlic pizza varieties, are transcendent – crisp on the edges, bursting with fresh toppings and perfectly melted cheese. Standouts like the Strawberry Cheesecake and Coconut Cream Pie linger on the palate, delivering a nostalgic, comforting finish that keeps guests coming back.

It’s more than just food here — it’s an experience wrapped in old-school Italian charm. The atmosphere channels a warm, inviting vibe that makes you feel as though you’re dining in your favorite Italian nonna’s kitchen. Customers often praise the personable and attentive staff, elevating every visit with genuine hospitality that feels rare these days.

As one delighted patron, Aryn Tew, put it, “Soprano’s Market is a gem in Waverly. The food is excellent, the service is warm and attentive, and the atmosphere has that classic oldschool Italian charm that makes you feel right at home.” This sentiment is echoed by visitors like Madelyn Bailey, who swears by the breakfast pizza, calling it "INCREDIBLE," and Isabella Cervantes, who hails Soprano’s Reuben as “THE best” she’s ever tasted after an extensive search.

Although the vast majority of feedback radiates with praise, there have been a few isolated notes on inconsistency in baked goods and occasional lapses in customer service. Still, the welcoming environment and the incredible flavors these ovens produce keep the faithful coming back again and again.

Whether you’re craving a robust breakfast to kickstart your morning, a satisfying deli lunch, or a sweet, indulgent treat to brighten your day, Soprano’s Market offers a uniquely comforting and authentic taste of Italian-American cuisine with heart. It’s a local treasure where every slice of pizza, every cupcake, and every salad tells a story of tradition, passion, and homegrown excellence.

Visit Soprano’s Market at 607 Cayuta Ave to experience the warmth and flavors that make this Waverly favorite truly unforgettable.